Is It Halal or Haram? 10 Debates Every Muslim Group Chat Has Had

Every Muslim group chat has had this argument at least once: someone posts a screenshot, a scenario, a receipt — 40 messages later, nobody agrees and everyone's a little bit offended. That's the energy behind the Halal Haram Ratio Game. Here are 10 debates that never seem to die.

1. Is it okay to use dating apps if the intention is marriage?

Half the chat says niyyah (intention) is everything. The other half says the app itself is the problem, not the intention. Nobody's mind gets changed. Ever.

2. Working a job that serves alcohol (but you personally don't drink or serve it)

Hostess at a restaurant with a bar. Delivery driver for a grocery store that sells wine. Where's the line between "adjacent to haram" and "actually haram"?

3. Music — all of it, some of it, or none of it?

This one alone could end friendships. Nasheeds are safe. Everything past that is a group chat minefield.

4. Spending $300 on sneakers while your local masjid needs a new roof

Not technically haram. Definitely gets brought up at every family gathering.

5. Getting a mortgage vs. renting forever

The riba conversation that resurfaces every single time someone in the group buys a house.

6. Going to mixed-gender parties "just to support a friend"

The intention defense makes another appearance. So does the side-eye.

7. Skipping Jummah for a job interview

Necessity vs. priorities — and everyone has a different threshold for what counts as necessary.

8. Tattoos that have already healed — remove them or leave them?

The fiqh answers vary. The group chat answers vary more.

9. Following celebrity gossip accounts "for the memes"

Ghiba (backbiting) doesn't stop being ghiba just because it's funny.

10. Marrying someone less religious than you, if they're a genuinely good person

The debate that ends every iftar table conversation in a stalemate — and the one that inspired half the cards in this game.

Why these debates never get resolved

Because there usually isn't one clean answer — there's a spectrum, and everyone's standing somewhere different on it. That's the whole premise behind the Halal Haram Ratio Game: 65+ real scenarios like these, a vote, and a table full of people who are all convinced they're right. See how it's played or get your deck before this print run sells out.

Hosting a bigger or more mixed crowd — cousins who want less debate and more chaos? Our sibling game The Arab Card Game (trivia and meme editions) is built for that energy.